Learn
Cross-referencing and indirect identification
In short
- A person can be identified without their name, by combining a few pieces of information that each look harmless.
- The GDPR provides for it: data is personal as soon as it can identify someone, directly or indirectly.
- So removing the name is not always enough. You also need to look at what the other details, together, give away.
I didn’t put her name in, so nobody can tell who I’m talking about.
Often true. Not always.
Each detail rules people out
This is what the GDPR calls being identifiable indirectly (article 4). The CNIL, France’s data protection authority, describes it as identification by cross-matching a set of data (CNIL).
One detail says nothing. Together, they do.
What identifies
The rare: an unusual job, a small town, a rare disease, a dated event.
The combined: several common details put together.
What tells almost nothing
The very common: “an employee”, “a small business”.
Worth knowing: according to the CNIL, AI models tend to memorise rare data first (CNIL).
Three questions before you send
They follow the three criteria of the European data protection authorities (CNIL).
-
Singling out
Does my message describe a situation very few people are in?
-
Linking
Could it be matched with another source: a news article, an online profile, another of my conversations?
-
Inference
Does it let someone guess something sensitive: poor health, money trouble, a conflict?
The same message, twice
Help me write a reminder to Mrs Martin1, 522, who took over the village’s only pharmacy3 in March4. She has two overdue invoices.
- the name: she is identified directly
- not needed to write a reminder
- rare: only one possible person
- dated: even more precise
Help me write a polite reminder to a client, a shopkeeper, who has two overdue invoices.
The answer will be just as good. Try it!
- Remove what does not serve the question.
- Generalise the rest: “a rural town”, “in her fifties”.
- Beware of dates: “Tuesday’s accident” identifies better than a name.
- Reread it as a neighbour would: would they recognise the person?
There are no silly questions
- I took the name out. That’s anonymous, isn’t it?
- Not necessarily. If the rest of the message describes a unique situation, the person can still be recognised.
- Who would cross-check my messages?
- A conversation is linked to your account and adds to the others. Anyone who read it, during a review, a leak or legal proceedings, would read it in that context.
- Does a tool that replaces names solve the problem?
- It deals with direct identification, not cross-referencing. That is the subject of the page Pseudonymising: what it protects, and its limits.
Your turn: does this message point to someone?
“Rephrase this email to an employee who arrives late.”
No. “An employee” is a very common detail: it tells almost nothing.
“My neighbour, the only vet in the district, was taken to hospital on Tuesday.”
Yes. A rare detail, a dated event, and health information you can guess.
“A 45-year-old client is disputing his invoice.”
Not on its own. But add the town and the job, and the answer changes.
Key points
- A name is not the only way to point to someone: a combination of details can be enough.
- The rarer a detail, the more it identifies: an unusual job, a small town, a specific event.
- Before sending, remove the details that do not serve the question, and generalise the others.
- Replacing names with pseudonyms reduces the risk, without dealing with cross-referencing.
Sources
- CNIL, Identifier les données personnelles (27 January 2020) (in French), consulted .
- CNIL, Règlement européen sur la protection des données, chapitre 1 (article 4) (in French), consulted .
- CNIL, Le G29 publie un avis sur les techniques d’anonymisation (25 January 2016) (in French), consulted .
- CNIL, IA : Analyser le statut d’un modèle d’IA au regard du RGPD (22 July 2025) (in French), consulted .
This page is for information only. It is not legal advice and does not replace a professional’s view of your situation. Rules change: each source is dated with the day it was consulted.