By profession

AI in a chartered accountancy firm

Updated

In short

  • In France, chartered accountants (experts-comptables) and their staff are bound by professional secrecy, with criminal penalties.
  • Their professional body says it plainly for AI: no client emails, FEC or DSN files that have not been anonymised in tools the firm does not control.
  • AI is still useful for drafting, finding ideas, writing a formula or explaining a rule, without the client’s data.

In a firm, generative AI can save time on many tasks: drafting, rephrasing, looking up a rule, writing a formula. But client files are covered by professional secrecy, and they contain personal data. Here is how to reconcile the two, with situations you have probably come across.

The rules that apply

Three everyday situations

Looking for anomalies in an accounting entries file

In the middle of an audit, a member of staff wants to upload a client’s FEC (fichier des écritures comptables, the standard export of all accounting entries) to a consumer AI assistant and ask it to spot unusual entries.

What is the problem

The FEC holds the client’s entire accounts. Its descriptions often name customers, suppliers or employees. Uploading it to a tool the firm does not control means handing a third party information covered by professional secrecy: the profession’s body names the FEC precisely among what must not be uploaded.

The right move

Ask for the method rather than the analysis: which checks to run on a FEC, which spreadsheet formula spots duplicates or round amounts. Then apply it yourself in your usual tools. If the firm has an approved AI tool covered by a contract, that is the one to use for the data.

Replying to a delicate email from a client

A client disputes a fee invoice in a long, tense email that mentions her company’s cash-flow difficulties. You want the AI to help you reply tactfully.

What is the problem

Copying the email as it is sends the client’s name, her company’s name, amounts and sensitive information about her financial situation. The profession’s body names client emails among what must not be uploaded without anonymising them.

The right move

Describe the situation in one or two sentences, with no name or figure: “A client disputes a fee increase; she is going through a difficult period. Help me reply firmly and with empathy.” Then complete the draft yourself with the real details.

A payroll question about a specific employee

For an employer client, you are running the payroll of an employee who has been on sick leave for three months. You are unsure about continued pay and think of pasting the payslip and the DSN extract (déclaration sociale nominative, the monthly payroll filing) into the AI.

What is the problem

The payslip and the DSN identify the employee and reveal their sick leave, so health information. Neither the employee nor the employer agreed that it would leave the firm. The profession’s body names the DSN among what must not be uploaded.

The right move

Ask the question in general terms: “How is continued pay calculated after three months of sick leave, for an employee with five years’ service?” Check the answer on an official source and in the collective agreement: the AI can be wrong or make things up.

What you can still do without special precautions

  • Writing an article, a post or a general newsletter for your clients.
  • Preparing a template email or engagement letter, without client data.
  • Having a tax, social or accounting rule explained, then checking it on an official source.
  • Writing a spreadsheet formula or a macro from a made-up example.
  • Finding ideas to organise the firm: onboarding process for a new client, schedule, checklist.

Try it with a document from this profession

The demo shows, on a fictional document from this profession, what would be sent to the AI, its pseudonymised version, then two answers side by side. The documents are in French. Open the demo.

Key points

  • Professional secrecy also covers the firm’s staff and trainees.
  • FEC, DSN and client emails do not go, without anonymising them, into a tool the firm does not control.
  • Ask the AI for a method, a template or an explanation; keep the client’s data in your own tools.
  • Always check the answer: AI can be confidently wrong.

Sources

  1. Légifrance, Ordonnance n° 45-2138 du 19 septembre 1945, article 21 (version in force since 24 December 2016) (in French), consulted .
  2. Légifrance, Code pénal, article 226-13 (version in force since 1 January 2002) (in French), consulted .
  3. Conseil national de l’ordre des experts-comptables, Comment utiliser ChatGPT ? Notice pour les cabinets d’expertise comptable (precautions for use and model charter) (in French), consulted .
  4. Conseil national de l’ordre des experts-comptables, Travaux Data et IA (in French), consulted .
  5. CNIL, Règlement européen sur la protection des données, chapitre 1 (article 4) (in French), consulted .

This page is for information only. It is not legal advice and does not replace a professional’s view of your situation. Rules change: each source is dated with the day it was consulted.